|
development and condo watch
There are several condos STAND is watching and resisting.
Here are some of the worst we have seen.
The Hauser Project or "Creekover" referred to by some Community Creek Faces Oblivion, 5132 Telegraph. Global Video store site.
Hauser Architects plan a modern-looking, 115 unit, condos over commercial, 6-story, condo (2 stories over what the zoning allows). They claim a CEQA infill exemption. “The Creekside” will cover Temescal Creek, thus preventing it from being daylighted, and shade Frog Park.This building is twice the density of the already approved “Civic” project next door and doesn’t fit into the architecture of the neighborhood. Hauser Architects is in the midst of Environmental Review & Community Input meetings on this 118 unit, 6 Story Condo & Retail development planned for the Global Video Site. This building is twice the density of the already approved "Civic" project next door and doesn't fit into the architecture of the neighborhood. This project is 2 stories over current zoning and the density us more than 50% above current zoning. There will be excessive shadowing of Frog Park existing housing, & increased traffic congestion projected for a 2-3 block radius. RCPC has joined us in our opposition, & we are working together to try to bring this project down to a neighborhood-conforming size. No date has been set for City Design Review or Project Approval. To track this one, Dahn Van Laarz: bootlvr@yahoo.com. Planned for Telegraph on the Global Video site
4801 Shattuck Roy Alper, Ron Kriss, Kahn Architects plan a 44 unit, 5-story condo (only 3 allowed on 1/2 of site). They claim a CEQA infill exemption. The project will remove 4 buildings and 3 older rentals (5 units of affordable rentals and 1 architecturally significant building). STAND also believes the modern design will not fit in with its surroundings.
The new building will stretch from the corner of 48th and Shattuck to another box by the same developers, Gate 48. It will overwhelm its neighbors – the Omni Club, Casa Bella, and single-story Victorians -- cast the housing in shadows, add to traffic congestion, and inflate land values that fan the interest of developers.
The City and the developers have done NO study of the CUMULATIVE impacts on Temescal with all of the market rate condo projects. For 4801, the Planning Commission allowed only one parking space per unit and waived the developer providing ground floor commercial, ignoring the staff recommendation and the EIR for Oakland's General Plan. And there will be no commercial space, although recommended by Planning staff, community, and the General Plan. Planning Commission approved project and granted 6 variances. STAND believes this type of development will only diminish the historical character of the community (why people moved here) and result in out-of-control traffic and the loss of parking, views, sunlight, affordable housing and commercial spaces. Gate 48, now completed has unsold units rented out. On this one, after appealing all the way to the City Council, STAND decided to go to court and challenge the City's granting of excessive variances, and reliance of the "CEQA infill exemption" to shoehorn in one project after another. We raised a significant amount of money, but lost the first round in Superior Court. We have until the end of July to appeal. To track this one, Robert Brokl, broklcrofts@earthlink.net Planned for 4801 Shattuck
5666 Telegraph
Kahn Design of Berkeley & Developer Tom Anthony have proposed a 5+ story 15 unit Market-Rate Condo project with no retail on the site of the Telegraph Vet Hospital. Their design calls for 2 towers atop a concrete parking structure for up to 36 cars; the front tower rising to 58 feet, the rear to 48 feet. These would be the tallest buildings north of Hwy 24 on telegraph by far, shading neighboring affordable rentals & single-family homes thru much of the year. The buildings would also loom over Idora Park & block views of the bay from BART & Hwy 24. Current Zoning, if followed, would limit the structure to 40 feet at the front, 30 feet in the rear, & encourage retail space along Telegraph. The project & all variances received an administrative approval from the Planning Department in October, over the objections of 35 neighbors. The approval went so far as to declare this project as a precedent for 5-6+ story buildings the length of Upper Telegraph, overriding existing Zoning. An appeal to the full Planning Commission was spearheaded by STAND member Dahn Van Laarz. Now, this 5 story 15 unit market-rate condo project sits approved & un-built after a contentious battle by STAND & project neighbors. Planning approved the project last Oct. over the objections of large numbers of neighbors even though is was 18-20 feet over zoning height limits, would severely shade neighboring affordable housing ,and sets a precedent for taller buildings on Upper Telegraph. STAND & Neighbors appealed to the Planning Commission & lost, even though Commissioners voiced misgivings. A CEQA suit was filed in March, & due to unfavorable rulings on parallel suits, was settled in May. STAND prevailed in getting many shading issues mitigated and in forcing a number of design changes to lessen the building's visible bulk. To track this one, contact Dahn Van Laarz: bootlvr@yahoo.com The KingFish Project Co-Housing with High Density Does Not Ensure Diversity, 5244 Telegraph
Roy Alper, Ron Kriss, Tom Dolan Architects plan a 33 unit, 5-story (zoning allows only 4) project with ground floor commercial on Telegraph & Claremont. They claim a CEQA Infill Exemption. STAND is concerned that the building is too tall (over 45’) and too dense. Plus, 2 Victorians, 5 affordable housing units and the historic Kingfish bar will be removed. There will also be a parking impact because the site offers reduced parking. STAND applauds co-operative living but is concerned that the units may revert to condos later. Design Review approved it with minor changes. They claim a CEQA infill exemption. Kingfish Pub, NoCoHo, and STAND all lose on this one, 5244 Telegraph STAND took the fight over this one all the way to the City Council.
Same developers--Kriss, Alper, Zimski--as 4801 Shattuck. This project is 5 stories, 33 units. The Kingfish Pub, Victorian cottages and 7 units of rent-controlled housing will be demolished. This project was sold to the commission as co-housing. After our appeal was denied at the City Council, lo and behold the co-housers are revealed to be out of the deal, unable to afford the readjusted construction costs. Who would have guessed? Except that STAND suggested this was the likely scenario from the get-go. Full expose "NoCoho at the Kingfish: Anatomy of a Deception" in the May 29-June 4, 2008 Berkeley Daily planet, www.berkeleydailyplanet.com. /To track this one, Robert Brokl, broklcrofts@earthlink.net The Planning Commission denied the appeals from both RCPC and STAND.
Planned for 5244 Telegraph
5300 San Pablo Ave at 53rd Community Fights for Equality,
Dogtown Developers & Banta Architects plan a 32 unit, 5-story building adjacent to single family housing. Traffic patterns, light and height are a concern. They claim a CEQA infill exemption. The community and planning staff fought hard to get meaningful commercial space designed into the project but lost. The Planning Commission approved the project but the neighbors have appealed to the City Council.
989 41st St. (between Linden and Market) One Person Can Make a Difference,
Pocket Development & David Baker Architect plans a 48 unit, 3-story townhouse project (40 units/acre).An industrial conversion to residential is twice the density allowed under the general plan. The site is surrounded by single family homes and duplexes. They claim a CEQA infill exemption. Both the developer and the City bypassed existing zoning and General and failed to the design to a future update of the zoning code. It still has 4 zoning violations. There was no contact with, or input from, the neighborhood. Project was appealed. City allowed Developer to drop application and reapply the same day with the same project (needing more variances). Planning Commission approved again. Appealed again August '07 and has been in limbo ever since, with no contact from the developer, the Planner not working on the appeal, property vacant and blighted. To track this one, contact George Nesbit geoedb@idiom.com 5175 Broadway
A 5 story condo with commercial is being planned on a former gas station-vacant lot. The project was sent back to Design Review since Planner's thought it was ugly. New Architect made positive changes working with the neighbors and Staff. Approved June 4th at Planning Commission with concerns about traffic, and some direction to the traffic department to look at the issue. An improvement over the process for many projects, but more community input needed before it goes to Planning Commission for approval, or has to be sent back to 2 more meetings. To track this one, contact George Nesbit: geoedb@idiom.com. MacArthur Bart Transit Village
A development with 600 plus condos is moving forward with an EIR in the works and preliminary project approvals. It has some affordable units and a Bridge Housing Affordable Rental project included some commercial along Telegraph. It will be 5-6 stories with 1 parking space per unit (1/2 required), but the loss of 1/2 (300) BART parking spaces. Concern from neighborhood as well as Planning Commission to the impact of loss parking. Project will be back several times in the next 1-1/2 years or so for a variety of approvals. To track this one, contact George Nesbit: geoedb@idiom.com. Safeway on College Ave.
Safeway wants to build a new store on the combined sites of the existing 1960's Safeway store, the parking lot, and the Union 76 gas station. The store would be increased from the existing 23,000 sq. ft. to 75,000 sq. ft. with the store at 59,000 sq. ft. and street retail at 16,000 sq. ft. and would cover the entire 1.8 acre site with one massive contiguous structure. Safeway has posted their plans on their website, www.safewayoncollege.com. The neighborhood believes that size is totally inappropriate for the existing neighborhood. For more information contact: safewayneighbors@sbcglobal.net |
|